Phishing simulation

A phishing simulation is an authorized exercise that presents a controlled deceptive message to observe or practice how recipients and organizational processes respond.

Decide what you want to learn

A simulation can show whether people recognize a suspicious request, report it, or take the requested action. Decide which behavior matters before sending the messages. Clicking, reporting, and attempting to disclose information are different observations.

NIST describes simulated phishing as part of embedded awareness training. Its Phish Scale helps assess how difficult an email is for its audience to recognize. That context matters when interpreting click rates.

Someone can click and still report

Use a controlled landing page to record the test interaction without collecting real passwords. Track reports separately, including whether they reached the team responsible for responding.

A person who clicks and then reports has done two things worth understanding. Counting only the click hides a useful response. Exclude undelivered messages when calculating a rate based on delivered messages.

Compare similar exercises

Record the audience, delivery status, requested action, message difficulty, and observation window. Fewer clicks on an easier follow-up message do not necessarily mean training improved judgment.

Email results also cannot tell you how someone would handle a phone call or recovery request. Test those workflows separately.

Sources

See it in practice